The Online Reefer Madness Teaching Museum.Org
An
Online History
Museum Of Reefer Madness Propaganda
|
*************************
*************************
*************************
And The Maine Patients Coalition.org **************************** Chris Kenoyer. Owner Email Us Here At 1999-2009 Copyright © |
The Online Reefer Madness Teaching MuseumThe Canada Lancet - Vol. 17 - 1884 pp101 A CASE OF DOUBLE NARCOTIC ADDICTION.---OPIUM AND
ALCOHOL.---IMBECILITY---RECOVERY. Recovery With Indian Hemp BY J. B. MATTISON, M.D., BROOKLYN, N.Y. Through the courtesy of Drs. T. Gaillard Thomas, of New York, and Wm. Bayard, of St. John, N.B., there came under the writer's care last year a case of combined opinm and alcohol taking, presenting a history and result of such importance as probably to render its recital one of interest to the readers of the LANCET. Mrs. ----, of Canada, aet. 34, in the summer of 1881, passed through her second accouchement during the eighth month of gestation. Her recovery was tedious, involving four to five months, during which she had much discomfort from alvine torpor, and also underwent an operation for the relief of fistula in ano. The latter was attended by severe pain, to relieve which her medical adviser gave morphia hypodermically, and supplying her with a syringe instructed her and the attendant in its use. This was in July, and the initial dose of the morphia was 1/8 of a grain, repeated three or more times daily, when the pain was severe. She made a fair recovery from this illness, except that the power of her lower limbs was largely lost, due, it was thought, to the morphia---which she had steadily taken---and a lack of active exercise. She had now become a confirmed habitue and during the next two years used her opiate in increasing quantity and frequency, often repeating it every three or four hours. During the autumn of 1883 she came under the care of a medical gentleman who was called to relieve her of severe abdominal pain and nervous derangement. Prior to this time no attempt had been made to abandon the morphia. Her new medical adviser, appreciating the situation, strongly urged an effort in that direction, but without success. Her condition had steadily grown worse, aggravated as it was by an inordinate use of brandy, of which she took at times from I2 to 16 ounces daily. From October, 1883, her mental and physical decline was marked, the most prominent symptoms being anorexia, insomnia, nausea, incessant thirst, subsultus, loss of memory, delirium, hallucinations and partial imbecility. Her physician now insisted on stopping her stimulants, and succeeded with the brandy, while the morphia, which had been increased to several grains, three to five per diem, was reduced to one or two injections daily. Despite this treatment her mental and physical status steadily deteriorated until she became completely imbecilic, and in this condition, on December 21, 1883, she came under the writer's care. So weak was she prior to leaving home that some of her friends deemed it hazardous to make the effort, fearing she would not survive the journey, but under the watchful care of Dr. Bayard, it was safely effected. Her physical debility on arriving was so great that she was carried from her carriage. Mentally she was a wreck. Delusions were prominent, and hallucinations of sight, sound and touch almost constant, that of touch being especially marked, patient fancying bugs and reptiles crawling over her. Her expression was idiotic; she was utterly unable to converse intelligibly, and her voice in speaking speedily sank to a whisper and was lost. In fact such mental ravages from opium we never met. Physically, she was partially prostrated, pulse frequent and feeble, marked anorexia, furred tongue and alvine torpor ; in fine, all the symptoms before noted except delirium and subsultus. During her coming, in order to maintain her strength, she had taken milk punch freely, and was given one or two half grain injections of morpbia daily. Such was her status oh arrival. There was no history of hereditary insanity. The case seemed clearly one of profoundly pernicious results from her double addictions, aggravated by a laudable effort to remove the cause. This being our belief, the prognosis, was favorable, an opinion endorsed by Dr. John C. Shaw, Superintendent of the King's Co. Insane Asylum, who was called in consultation, and verified by the result, as the further record of the case will show. As a prelude to active treatment the patient was given a mild mercurial which acted well. No alcohol was allowed from the outset, and at the end. of a week the morphia-which previously had been given in small doses by mouth at bed-time-was quite abandoned, and reliance placed on large doses of Indian hemp to secure sleep. As tonics she was given daily seances of electricity, with syr. of the hypophosphites of iron, strychnia and quinine, in two drachm doses, ter die, and full feeding. The good effect of this regime soon declared itself, for in less than a fortnight, signs of improvement presented. The earliest of these were mental. The delusions lessened and the hallucinations departed, the last to leave being those of touch which persisted for some time after the patient was able to realize that they were only the vagaries of her disordered brain. With this amendment came a better brain status in other ways. The imbecilic look gave place to one of increasing intelligence ; the power to converse rapidly returned, and within six weeks all mental aberration had vanished. Meantime, the physical condition gradually improved, though not so speedily as the mental. The appetite was slow in returning, but her muscular strength, especially in the lower limbs, the loss of which for two and a half years, had prevented exercise, increased steadily, so that at the end of eight weeks she was able to take walks, drives, go shopping, attend church, etc., in fact, more out of door exercise than she had enjoyed for years. Her improvement in every way was notable and persisted with little interruption until March 4---nearly eleven weeks from the date of her coming---when she left our care. Tidings, direct and indirect, of late received, report her doing well. This case presents several points worthy of detail. Its origin affords added proof in support of views expressed in "The Genesis of Opium Addiction," Detroit Lancet, Jan. 1884. But it must also be said that, in our judgment, the course of the medical gentlemen in supplying this patient with a hypodermic syringe and solution of morphia, with instructions for self-taking, unless absolutely unavoidable, was-to put it mildly---exceedingly indiscreet. Such action and advice are almost certain to end in addiction; the effect, even under professional attention, is, too often, disastrous, and the chance of escaping, when left to caprice of the patient, is small indeed. We believe that patients should never be allowed to give themselves injections, if at all possible to avoid it. When her initial illness ended, this patient was an opium habitue. A much more limited time than that will often suffice. We have repeatedly known as many weeks to beget addiction, and the most marked examples of this were among those in whom it might be supposed the least likely to occur-physicians. Increased experience serves only to strengthen the writer's opinion, as expressed in a paper on "Opium Addiction among Medical Men," that "any physician using morphia, daily or oftener---especially hypodermically---for four weeks incurs great risk of becoming an habitue; indeed we think a still shorter usage might, with some, prove a snare." This case adds another to the instances in which addiction to one narcotic tends to excess in another. While these are infrequent as compared with those in which one is used, they are sometimes quite notable. We recall that of a Canadian gentleman who some time ago consulted us, who had taken for several years 10 to 20 grains of morphia subcutaneously, 60 to 90 grains of chloral, and 1 to 2 pints of whiskey, daily. Physical examination disclosed organic heart lesion, and care of his case was declined. As a rule, the ruinous results exceed those of a single addiction, while the prospect of permanent cure is always less hopeful. In our patient the pernicious effect on the brain was notable-more so than we have ever seen. While deviations from normal cerebral action are sometimes observed in cases of confirmed opium taking, it is rare that they are so pronounced as in this instance. Doubtless they were aggravated by the alcohol, yet morphia was the main factor. And it is of interest to note that the attempt at renouncing the narcotics intensified the mental disorder. Obersteiner---Brain, Oct.,'82--- demurring to Levinstein's statement that the Psychical disturbances caused by morphia cease within a few hours, affirms that " mental diseases arising in the course of morphinism are of the most intractable kind when once fully developed. Not only do they not disappear on depriving the patient of morphia, but they then usually get worse." This case tends to prove the latter part of his statement. As one medical gentleman informed us-" The condition in which you saw her was the result of the addictions aggravated by the attempt to quit them." But the mental disorder was not of the "most intractable kind," for improvement was prompt and progressive, much more so than anticipated, as it was thought several months rather than weeks would be needed to repair the damaged brain. Regarding alienation caused by opium, Obersteiner thinks it frequent, asserting that "a man who consumes large quantities of morphia during a number of years will display many nervous symptoms, and that the continued intoxication attacks the Psychical much more constantly than the somatic life." He further states: "The degree of mental aberration arising from protracted use of the drug is very variable. There may, indeed, be individuals who retain their power of mind in spite of it, but the number is much greater of those who betray a marked alteration of their intellectual and moral life; and in not a few cases finally the point of distinct aberration is reached. This usually consists of a depressed state, with suicidal tendencies, occasionally with violent excitement and hallucinations;" and he sums up his views with the statement that "In most cases the protracted use of morphia in large doses is followed by Psychical alterations of a lasting nature, which may amount to decided insanity." With these opinions we are not in full accord. Our experience has been much more favorable. We have observed many cases of opium addiction, among them those who had taken morphia in large amounts for several years, yet the number with marked mental derangement has been small. Depression has been common; so, too, irritability of temper; but we recall only one instance in which suicidal or homicidal tendency existed, and but a single case that we deemed "decided insanity." Far oftener physical symptoms presented. In some form, these have been almost constant, so that, on this score also, our observation has been at variance with Obersteiner. Regarding treatment, one point deserves special mention---that is, the effect of Indian hemp in large doses. In this instance it quite maintained the power ascribed to it by Moreau of removing hallucinations. Again and again, often by the patient, was this noted. Its hypnotic action also was very satisfactory. As a soporific, in ex-opium habitues, cannabis indica is of great value. They may be peculiarly susceptible to its good effect, but certain it is we know of nothing equalling it, and employ it almost exclusively. For details regarding its use, vide "The Treatment of Opium Addiction," Courier of Medicine, Dec., 1884. Finally, the history of this case is of value as warranting hope of entire recovery under conditions that, seemingly, offer little promise of success. Back to Reefer Madness Page #1 |